|
Every true history must force us to remember that the past was once as real as the present and as uncertain as the future.
G. M. Trevelyan, British historian
MONETIZING / SELLING RECOVERED PROPERTY
This webpage will be soon updated and revised.
Q. What can be done with a
recovered property in Poland?
A. Once the property
is recovered, it is owned by heirs and their title is marketable. Their
monetizing
options are similar to those in America and other western countries.
Most foreign owners sell
the properties they recover in Poland. A minority holds them —
for income
and /or further appreciation of value.
Over the last 10
years or so, we have observed that some heirs develop the properties
they
recover, typically by building on them a number of individual homes,
apartment
buildings, or even high-rises. They generally work in partnership with
local
developers. The real estate market in Poland is lively.
Recently, a few foreign heirs
asked us to make development arrangements for them, in order to
maximize their
monetization.
Q. Can the sale proceeds or
income be transferred outside Poland?
A. Naturally. Communism ended in Poland in 1989, long ago. Nowadays,
Polish
currency, the zloty (symbol PLN or ZŁ) is fully convertible and there
are no
restrictions on transfer of funds out of the country.
Just as Polish residents, foreigners
are subject taxes on inheritance and income derived from Poland. Taxes
in
Poland are moderate. This is another matter. See Tax Issues.
Q. Who arranges the monetization
of the recovered rights?
A. This can be done in different ways. Most of the time, our
compensation
includes a significant contingent component (in some cases, the bulk of
our
fees) payable upon monetization. In such situations, as a rule, our
responsibilities comprise the recovery and the monetization of
properties — i.e. a
sale at a reasonable price or, when applicable, the obtaining of
reasonable Indemnification
from governmental bodies.
However, we are busy enough
and do not mind if the client makes his own monetization arrangements,
provided
we are promptly paid our contingent fee in full.
Q. How important are
monetization arrangements?
A. They are very important. The following
are only some of the elements of paramount importance in monetization
arrangements:
- In many situations several heirs inherit shares in the same
assets (“joint heirs”). In this context it is important to note that
generally, one obtains
better prices by selling the entire property or a majority interest in
it, as
compared with selling only a minority interest.
- For this reason, when we
work for joint heirs, we require them to
act in concert with each other, including at monetization.
- We have come across cases in which
foreign heirs
(and
elderly heirs living in Poland) received only a small fraction of the
realizable
value (in one extreme case less than 10% but often around one-third),
because,
without any verification or control, they entrusted monetizing
transaction to
persons
unworthy of trust.
- We, however, inform heirs in
writing of true market values, provide general transparency and
ultimate-seller-control for all monetizing transactions.
- It should be noted that
Polish law allows intermediaries, such as realtors, to
receive commission from both the seller and the buyer. In situations
involving
a foreign seller, some intermediaries view the foreign seller as the
proverbial
“absentee owner” and quietly team up with local buyers to arrange sales
at
unreasonably low prices.
- When we are involved, we
do not allow this.
Q. What should the selling
price
be?
A. The sale price should be at market value. When Indemnification is
accepted from the government, it should also be at
market value, or at the going rate for Indemnifications paid for
similar
properties in the relevant area.
Q. How do we ensure that
our clients receive reasonable prices or reasonable Indemnification?
A. We do this via a number of measures, which we incorporate into our
Agreements.
Most importantly, we
align our interests
completely with the heirs — our clients.
In our Agreements we commit not to receive remuneration other than that
specified in these
Agreement. We provide heirs with written
information on market prices and Indemnification rates prior to
recommending
how they should respond to offers received. We encourage and assist
heirs to
obtain additional
appraisals, if they wish.
When we work with Polish
realtors we make sure they receive a motivating commission, but do not
allow
them to receive a remuneration from other parties in relevant
transactions
Under our Agreements, the heirs
retain control over the sale or acceptance of the Indemnification and
the
transfer of their recovered rights is made only against full payment
in
cash.
View from
Wawel Hill, Krakow,
by Jakub Hałun (Own Work), Krakow, Poland, via Wikimedia
Commons,
|